14 Comments
User's avatar
Monica Hay's avatar

I love this so much. I decided to write a short story a week for 6 months this year, not to “produce” or anything. Just to make lots of shitty art. Just to practice.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth Aman's avatar

I love this idea! What a great way to "get reps in" (to use a gym metaphor). I might have to steal this idea.

Expand full comment
Keetha's avatar

I am a visual artist and very much taking this to heart. I get so caught up in planning the best way to do a project - or anything creative - "right" that I end up so tight and fraught over it that I hardly start. This is a great piece - thank you!

Expand full comment
Elizabeth Aman's avatar

Love this! Also, I wonder... I know you've mentioned on the Podcast that you're not super enticed/motivated by the idea of publishing your novels, but are more motivated by the process. Do you feel like publishing something weekly on Substack has helped push you towards a mindset of "publishing=good" - as in it's helping you get over a need for perfectionism in order to publish your writing?

Expand full comment
James Winestock's avatar

I hadn't thought about it that way before but YES, I feel like I'm much closer to actually wanting to publish my novels. Now that you mention it, I've probably taken more steps in the last six months or so than I have in the previous few years. Definitely getting me more in the publishing mindset!

Expand full comment
Andrew Lynch's avatar

I’ve been thinking lately, how perfectionism might creep into the mind of a child when they start to realize how much effort it takes to make something polished.

In western culture, we like smooth plastic things because if it were made by hand, it would take an enormous amount of effort for the finish to have that look.

It’s not until we’re older that we realize a knife with a beautifully carved wood handle is worth more to us than the same blade with a molded plastic one.

What exacerbates this phenomenon is the fact that the beautiful option just doesn’t exist.

Expand full comment
Leenadria's avatar

It’s annoying that it’s taken me so long to arrive to this same conclusion but yes…to all of it.

Expand full comment
Beth Backes's avatar

Wholeheartedly agree with all of this!

Expand full comment
Eline Arlt's avatar

Very much learning this too! I just see how much I self-sabotage through perfectionism, but I like the idea of indeed seeing writing as a daily practiced craft. Want to make it more into a habit!

Expand full comment
Sonia Bavistock's avatar

"I’m training to be the writer I will be in the future." - this is such a powerful and freeing statement! Thank you for reminding me to get my writing reps in.

Expand full comment
Faith 🌷's avatar

Really good one, this actually helped me. Thanks James! Keep it upppp 💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼

Expand full comment
You Belong Here's avatar

1-3 reps is so relatable and easy to reach. My form of perfectionism is fear of being misunderstood or hurting someone with my writing… things that are out of my control. But you’re right, if I practice weekly, I’ll get better

Expand full comment
Cassie Wilkins's avatar

This was a beautiful permission slip! Thanks James :)

Expand full comment
Katie Larry's avatar

Thank you thank you thank you. I feel like I’m in the messy middle in every aspect of life right now. I woke up feeling so much shame about it. After reading this, I feel empowered by the messy middle. Your writing did that. Thanks a million.

Expand full comment